Timeshares Are Not Investments: Why That Comparison Is Misleading

Many timeshare owners remember hearing some version of this during their sales presentation:

• “This is real estate.”
• “It’s an investment in your future.”
• “You’re locking in value now before prices go up.”

For buyers who are cautious, financially responsible, or planning for retirement, this framing matters. If a purchase is perceived as an investment, the risks feel lower and the long-term commitment feels justified—until they realize that a permanent timeshare exit is often the only way to protect their remaining assets.

The problem is that timeshares do not function like investments in any meaningful financial sense.

How the Investment Narrative Is Introduced

In most sales presentations, the word “investment” is rarely used casually. It is introduced deliberately, often alongside familiar concepts.

Owners frequently report comparisons such as:

• “It’s like buying property instead of renting vacations”
• “Real estate always goes up”
• “You’re building equity instead of wasting money on hotels”
• “This will hold value better than cash”

These statements are designed to anchor the timeshare purchase to traditional real estate and long-term financial planning, even though the underlying product behaves very differently.

What Defines a True Investment?

At a basic level, an investment has several core characteristics:

• Appreciation potential: The ability to grow in value over time.
• Control: Power over resale and exit strategy.
• Predictable costs: Manageable carrying costs.
• Market demand: Based on organic interest from buyers.
• Liquidity: The flexibility to sell if circumstances change.

Most timeshares meet none of these criteria.

Why Timeshares Do Not Appreciate

Unlike traditional real estate, timeshares are sold into a market with unlimited new supply. Resorts can continue selling new points or memberships indefinitely. This constant creation of new inventory suppresses any potential appreciation of existing ownerships.

At the same time, maintenance fees increase over time, reducing the attractiveness of older units. As detailed in our analysis of maintenance fee math, the longer an owner holds a timeshare, the less appealing it becomes to a potential buyer.

Lack of Owner Control

Investment assets allow owners to make decisions that affect value. Timeshare owners do not control pricing, availability, usage rules, or even fee increases. All of these are governed by the resort or management company.

Carrying Costs That Never End

Traditional investments typically have carrying costs that are fixed, predictable, or optional. Timeshares are different. Maintenance fees continue indefinitely, increase regularly, and must be paid regardless of use. These fees act as a permanent drag on value.

[!IMPORTANT] A Financial Drag. Even if an owner paid nothing upfront for a timeshare, the long-term cost of ownership (annual fees + special assessments) would still be substantial.

Why Retirees Are Especially Targeted

For retirees, investment language can be particularly persuasive. The idea of converting travel spending into a “smart financial decision” feels responsible. We have worked with many clients who justified large purchases because they believed they were reallocating money into an asset rather than an expense. Years later, they found themselves managing rising fees on a fixed income, with no way to recover their principle.

The Upgrade Trap Revisited

Once a timeshare is framed as an investment, upgrades become easier to justify. Owners are told they are "protecting their investment" or that a "higher version holds value better." In reality, upgrades often compound the problem by increasing exposure without changing the underlying economics.

The Moment of Truth

Most owners do not question the investment framing until something changes: retirement, health issues, or rising fees. At that point, they discover that what they believed was an asset behaves more like a liability.

This realization is often accompanied by frustration or self-blame. It is important to understand that the framing itself was misleading, not the owner’s judgment.

What Owners Should Know Now

If you purchased or upgraded because it was presented as an investment, keep these realities in mind:

• Timeshares are prepaid vacation products, not financial assets.
• They do not appreciate like real estate.
• Ongoing fees erode value over time.
• Exit options are limited and controlled by the resort.

---

A Clear Path Forward

At NW Advisors Group, we regularly work with owners who were encouraged to view their timeshare as an investment. Our role is to strip away the sales framing and evaluate the ownership based on how it actually functions today.

NW Advisors Group has been helping timeshare owners for over 15 years and is A+ rated and accredited with the Better Business Bureau.