Rental Income Promises: Why Timeshares Rarely Work as Rentals

One of the most damaging and misleading claims we see in timeshare sales presentations is the promise of rental income. Before betting your retirement on these claims, it's critical to understand the legitimate ways to exit a contract that no longer serves you.

For many owners, especially retirees, this is the moment the sale “makes sense.” Rising maintenance fees, limited usage, or hesitation about the purchase are reframed as an opportunity rather than a risk.

• “You can rent it when you’re not using it.”
• “It will help cover the fees.”
• “Some owners even make money.”

In practice, this promise almost never holds up.

How the Rental Income Pitch Is Introduced

Rental income is rarely presented as the sole reason to buy. Instead, it is introduced as a solution when an owner hesitates.

Common scenarios include:

• A retiree concerned about affordability.
• An owner questioning long-term use.
• A buyer worried about fixed income.
• Someone unsure about committing long term.

Rather than addressing those concerns directly, the timeshare is reframed as flexible and income-producing. This shifts the conversation away from cost and permanence and toward perceived opportunity.

Why This Pitch Is Especially Persuasive to Retirees

Retirees are often targeted because the pitch aligns with real financial anxieties. The idea of offsetting maintenance fees or turning an expense into an asset sounds responsible.

Some buyers are even encouraged to purchase timeshares close to where they live, reinforcing the idea that renting will be easy. What is rarely discussed is whether the numbers actually work.

The Financial Reality We See Every Day

We have worked with many clients who purchased specifically because of rental income promises. In some cases, purchases reached $250,000 or more, often financed through developer-arranged loans with interest rates ranging from 12.99% to 14.99% APR and terms of 10 to 15 years.

These buyers were retirees and near-retirees trying to make a responsible decision. When rental income failed to materialize, the damage was already done. This is a common pattern in timeshare sales targeting seniors.

Why Timeshares Rarely Rent Successfully

Timeshares are not designed to function as rental properties. Owners face structural barriers that make consistent income unlikely:

• Limited availability that doesn't align with peak demand.
• Competition from hotels and vacation rental platforms (Airbnb/VRBO).
• Resort restrictions on third-party rentals.
• Hidden costs: Marketing fees and time commitments.
• Pricing: Often fails to cover even the basic maintenance fees.

[!IMPORTANT] Listings Are Not Sales. Even when rentals occur, net income is often minimal or negative once fees and loan payments are accounted for.

The Myth of “Covering the Costs”

A common justification is that rental income will “at least cover the maintenance fees.” In reality, fees increase annually while loan payments remain fixed and demand fluctuates. One missed booking can erase months of progress, adding to the cost of waiting for a solution that never arrives.

When Rentals Fail, the Upgrade Pitch Returns

When owners report that renting didn’t work, the solution offered is often another purchase. Owners are told higher tiers rent better or that a newer product fixes what the last one didn't. This creates a dangerous cycle where rental failure is used to justify deeper financial commitment.

Why This Is a Major Red Flag

Any claim that a timeshare should be purchased primarily for rental income should be treated as a serious warning sign. Timeshares:

• Are not investments.
• Do not behave like rental real estate.
• Shift financial risk entirely onto the owner.
• Lock buyers into long-term obligations regardless of rental success.

What Owners Should Know Now

If rental income was part of your decision, it is important to understand:

• Rental success is uncommon and unreliable.
• Fees and debt continue regardless of results.
• Waiting rarely improves the situation.
• The structure does not change over time.

Realizing this is not a personal failure. It is a recognition that the model does not work the way it was presented.

---

A Clear Path Forward

At NW Advisors Group, we routinely help owners who were encouraged to rely on rental income that never materialized. Our role is to evaluate the ownership as it exists today and identify lawful, permanent exit options.

NW Advisors Group has been helping timeshare owners for over 15 years and is A+ rated and accredited with the Better Business Bureau.